BJ’s Tombstone History Discussion Forum

Joyce
You seem unwilling to accept the fact that the Dream Team did
speak to the witnesses you are concerned about.

It is possible they deemed it unwise to call them to the stand. The testimony would be harmful to their case may have been the correct decision.

Bob/ that is entirely possible... — Joyce A. Aros, Sat Nov 19 2022 15:48
...the problem is this is a court case 140 years old. We cannot guess or assume as we can only accept witness testimony. So we have to derive some logical and reasonable deductions from the statements... more
- Joyce — pat mulligan, Tue Dec 20 2022 8:35
- - Dream Team?... — Joyce A. Aros, Tue Dec 20 2022 10:04
    ...Here we go again! The 'dream team' were quite incompetent, without a doubt. On both sides. Fitch was better equipped as he came from some extensive experience back east where the methods of... more
  - - Further on Dream Team... — Joyce A. Aros, Sat Dec 24 2022 8:28
      ...as an afterthought, please note that the Prosecution had some very good witnesses with some damning observations in favour of the ranchers and yet they still floundered. This case should have been a... more
- You only call witnesses you think will help — Tom Gaumer, Sat Nov 19 2022 16:15
  Keep Laughing Tom
- - Upon cross examination, Ike became the best defense witness. (nm) — B.J., Sat Nov 19 2022 18:37
  - - I think Ike did well through most of his testimony — Tom Gaumer, Mon Nov 21 2022 4:22
      BJ But when he tried to sell the idea that the Earps and Holliday talked to him about murdering two people, which no one would do, He destroyed his crediibility. Also a good friend of Wyatts was shotgun... more
    - - If Ike really “did well through most of his testimony”… — B.J., Thu Nov 24 2022 23:34
        It would follow that Ike negated his own testimony? In summary: Ike became the defense’s best witness? Or are you still of the opinion that Ike: “Ike did well through most of his testimony” ... more
      - True (nm) — Tom Gaumer, Fri Nov 25 2022 15:41
    - - And claiming the Earp’s were piping away un-missing money (nm) — B.J., Mon Nov 21 2022 22:57
      - Yep (nm) — Tom Gaumer, Thu Nov 24 2022 13:29
  - - In what way, exactly? (nm) — Joyce A. Aros, Sun Nov 20 2022 3:46

Click here to receive daily updates