Joyce A. Aros
Pat/ Fuller's description of the Earp's....
Tue Dec 20, 2022 10:45

...Placement of their weapons took place while the Earp group was gathered in the intersection of Fourth and Allen streets. Fuller describes himself as "...standing on the corner of Fourth and Allen streets, I mean not far from them, about ten or twelve feet..."

Before cross-examination he said, "...he saw the Earp party, armed, at Fourth and Allen and that he was on his way down to warn Billy Clanton to get out of town..."

So his first observation of the Earps being fully armed and their weapons concealed or contained, was at that location. He headed down Allen toward the direction of the O.K. corral which could be approached from Allen or Fremont.

When he tried to approach the ranchers on the lot from the end that he accessed from Allen street, the first shots were already firing. He says he stayed in the alley but moved around during the shooting, as bullets were flying everywhere.

He did not see the Earp group approach with weapons in hand though he claims "...he thinks Morgan Earp and Doc Holliday fired the first two shots, but can't tell which fired first..."

This is possible as his concern was mainly for young Clanton and he may have seen some of the action, but he is not positive enough to rely on it.

It is noteworthy, without going into too much detail, that Spicer himself acknowledged that the Earps fired first, which convinces one that they had their guns in hand by the time they arrived on the scene. What sane law officer would approach armed men without having weapons at the ready? Fast draw artists are a thing of Hollywood. Bullet wounds were painful, often deadly, and few wished to sustain them if at all avoidable.

Spicer's words in his summation: "...They (the Earp group) saw at once the dire necessity of giving the FIRST shots, to save themselves from certain death!..."

Wyatt and Holliday, at least, definitely approached with guns in hand because they each prodded a rancher in the gut with their pistols. So why the need to shoot first, as the ranchers did not have guns out or they would have shot first to protect themselves? So the judge tripped himself up and admitted the Earps fired first!

It is worth noting that the Sheriff of Cochise County claimed he had no reason to believe the Earp group approached as a legitimate posse, as nothing was said to him to describe it as anything but personal. Remember, when Behan tried to stop them, they refused to acknowledge him or answer him. That was unprofessional.

There was not the need to shoot first! Only the Will!

  • Joycepat mulligan, Tue Dec 20 2022 9:18
    If you believe Wes Fuller testimony, his observations were made near the vacant Lot where the gunfight occurred. How can you continue to insist that the Earp LAWMAN POSSE entered the lot with guns drawn,... more
    • SoButch Badon, Wed Jan 04 15:04
      We all know that West Fuller was a "stand-up citizen. That means we should accept Fuller's account and completely dismiss the testimony of others? Butch
      • Butch/ So?...Joyce A. Aros, Thu Jan 05 5:48
        What is it you find questionable in Wes Fuller's testimony that we just discussed?
        • Nothing JoyceButch Badon, Thu Jan 05 12:50
          I am just saying that everyone who testified at that hearing had an agenda. And Fuller's is no more, or less important than any of the others'. The job of separating the wheat from the chaff belonged... more
          • Can't argue with that....Joyce A. Aros, Thu Jan 05 13:54
            Spicer was as crooked as a dog's hind leg, as my Grannie used to say!
    • Pat/ Fuller's description of the Earp's.... — Joyce A. Aros, Tue Dec 20 2022 10:45
      • Joyce FullerPat Mulligan, Sat May 06 8:36
        No one testified that more than one Cowboy was "poked in the stomach the Lawmen. The only testimony to this is Addie Bourland which seems to indicate Holliday did this to one of the McLaury's. Where... more